I'd rather go with Apogee ... not my taste by attitude and acting ... but handsome in his way.
A "handsome man" must not neccessary be a "pretty boy"
That's my thinking, too. Probably (under the right artist) he's supposed to be extremely, if ruggedly, handsome in a human, not elfin, way. He's also supposed to be very charming and persuasive. Then again, so many sociopaths are. (Think Ted Bundy.) I like that he wears his character on his face; that way you can tell he actually had to work to maintain and expand his kingdom.
I'd like to see him with chestnut or russet brown hair (if they ever get around to coloring EQ vol. 2). There are way too many black-haired humans (and villains) in the Quest. Let's have some variety for a change. :D