Wow, I would have made an offer of 40. I mean, they are slightly damaged after all. :?
Wow! They came damaged? That whomps :( But, since you've had them for a couple of years, that makes them used, even if they came with the damage which I noticed right from the start even before I read what you had said...then I read it :P But, yeah, I think $40.00 is a better price. The only way you'd be able to fairly sell these for the amount that you paid would be if they were unopened and unused. I'm just puttin' my two cents in there. ^_^
Actually, the reason why I could tell that it was damaged was because you showcased them side by side and one is clearly very bent while the other is not At any rate, I'm glad you got your sale. Good on ya! :D